Answer (7):

 
IQuarent

Selma Hayek, no contest. Heck, she STILL looks good.

 
Castle

...Damn.
I love Selma Hayek, but I had a huge crush in Tyra just because of how gorgeous she was. So, I'd have to say Tyra.

 
?

Tyra Banks.

 
Amy

Tyra Banks looked like a Barbie Doll back then. She was even a Barbie in one of her movies.

 
Alex

Salma

 
Jasmin

salma hayek hands down!

 
DAVID UNDERTAKER

Salma.