Are the Israeli settlements in the West Bank Illegal? If so why?


Share |

Why or why not? Detail please!


Banks in East Palestine, OH



Answer (5):

 
Petit

Yes they are according to UN Security Council, international community, international court of justice, and the whole world except Israel:
http://www.palestinemonitor.org/spip/spi...
Why? Because Israel captured these territories in war, countries can not claim ownership to lands acquired by war, and they can not build settlements for their citizens there.
Only Palestinian Arabs have legal claims to the West Bank including East Jerusalem because they didn't conquer it, but they inhabited it. Long before Jewish fanatics came from Europe.

 
camel urine

The word "palestine/filistin" is not even an arabic word by origin !, ask any scholar how do you say palestinians in arabic!? there isn't a word called palestinians in arabic because there isn't such nation!
arabs cant even pronounce the "P" in palestine since the "p" doesn't even exist in arabic ! they pronounce it "(B)alestine" or "(f)ilistin"
the word palestine/filistin comes from a LATIN via GREEK via
HEBREW word The Philistines (Hebrew פְלִשְׁתִּים, p'lishtim, lit. "invaders") from greece , Myceneans not- MUSLIM ARABs !!
(so in hebrew the word "palestinians" lit means = INVADERS)
the romans ( who changed the name from judea to syria-palestina) used the word to describe a -REGION- never a nation nor a country!
after the victory of the british army over the turks
the brits divided the land into 3 pieces, 2for the arabs one for the jews.(Transjordan was given to the "hashemite" from saudi arabia)
the arabs rejected the UN 2 state solution.
opened a holy "war 1948" against the israelites (7 countries VS 1 small israel) LOST land. and what do you know..
say hello to the EX-jordanians & egyptians =the "palestinians"
gaza was egypt before israel won it in the "Six-Day War 67" and the west bank was jordan there were no "PALESTINIANS" back then!
(ever wondered why the jordanian flag = hashemite flag, looks exactly like the fakestinian flag?)

its no mans land and any one can build there what ever he wants !
thats why the fakestinians never sued israel in international court.
they know they would lose !
since they NEVER had Sovereignty over the land !

 
wilbert

Yes and here's why In the 4th Geneva convention it clearly states in article 49 "The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies." Israel are members of the UN and must be aware of this and yet still choose to flaunt its rules

 
trancinguy

Yes, because of boats.

 
micho

because if it was legal israel was going to remove it.
but as israel loves everything illagal so it keeps it.